Please read the comments at the bottom of this page.
CHART 1. (From the files of Pam Duff Enright)

Pam Duff Enright's Version of Rachel's Tree

CHART 2. (From My Files)

My Version of Rachel's Tree

Pam and I differ on who was the father of William "Panther" Noble.
Pam has the original chart from Dorothy M. Noble (deceased) and it shows that "Panther's" father was George "Buckeye" Noble.
I have found evidence that indicates that "Panther's" father was Hiram Noble, and William "Panther" Noble was a brother of George "Buckeye" and John Warten Noble.